Skip to main content
Landlord Guide

Behind on the Mortgage on Your Rental Property: Options for Florida Landlords

Falling behind on a rental property mortgage feels different from falling behind on your own home. This guide explains the options available to Florida landlords, the tenant protections that apply, and the risks to watch for.

By Tyler Gibson Last updated October 1, 2026 ~11 min read
Spanish Spoken

Quick Answer

If you are behind on the mortgage on a rental property in Florida, you generally have four paths: work with your mortgage servicer on retention options such as forbearance, a repayment plan, or a Flex Modification; sell the property, including a short sale if you owe more than it is worth; transfer the property to the lender through a deed in lieu of foreclosure; or let the foreclosure process run its course. Investment properties get fewer protections than primary residences, and Florida law treats them differently when it comes to deficiency judgments. Your tenants have rights under the federal Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act, so any sale or foreclosure must account for their leases. The right path depends on your equity, your cash flow, your tenants, and your long-term goals.

What This Means for You

A rental property is a business asset, not your home. That changes almost everything about how a default is handled. You cannot claim Florida's homestead protections on a rental, the loss mitigation programs available to primary homeowners are often more limited for investment properties, and your personal credit and other assets can be exposed if you guaranteed the loan.

At the same time, you have options that can protect your tenants, your credit, and your finances. Servicers of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans are required to work through a loss mitigation hierarchy that applies to investment properties, starting with options that let you keep the property and moving to options that let you exit it in an orderly way.

The key is to act early, talk to your servicer, and understand the tenant rules before you commit to a path. Waiting usually narrows your choices and adds stress to everyone involved, including your tenants.

Why Investment Properties Are Different

Florida is a recourse state, which means a lender can generally pursue you personally for the unpaid balance after a foreclosure, a short sale, or a deed in lieu. The main protection for homeowners, the anti-deficiency rule that shields owner-occupied homes of four units or fewer, does not protect investment properties in the same way.

Florida Statute 702.036 does limit a lender's ability to pursue the forgiven balance after a short sale or deed in lieu when the loan is a purchase-money mortgage, meaning the loan was used to buy the property. If you refinanced, took cash out, or used the loan for other purposes, that protection may not apply, and the lender can pursue the difference unless you negotiate a written release.

Tenants are the other big difference. A rental property comes with a lease, and federal law protects tenants when a property is sold in foreclosure. Any plan you make has to include what happens to the people living there.

Your Options With the Mortgage Servicer

Servicers for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans follow a loss mitigation workout hierarchy that applies to loans on one-to-four-unit investment properties. Retention options, which let you keep the property, come first. If you cannot keep the property, non-retention options let you exit it in an orderly way.

Forbearance: A temporary pause or reduction in payments while you recover from a hardship. It does not erase the missed payments; you work out how to repay them afterward.

Repayment plan: An agreement to add a portion of the missed payments to your regular payments for a set period until you are caught up.

Flex Modification: A permanent loan modification that targets about a 20 percent payment reduction. On a conventional loan for a rental property, the modification is typically evaluated once the loan is 90 or more days delinquent. Borrowers who are less than 60 days delinquent usually must meet stricter conditions, including that the property is their primary residence, which a rental is not.

Ask your servicer which retention options are available on your specific loan and what documentation you need to provide. If you cannot keep the property, the servicer will move to non-retention options: a short sale or a deed in lieu of foreclosure.

Short Sale of a Rental Property

A short sale lets you sell the rental for less than the mortgage balance with the lender's approval. The lender agrees to accept the sale proceeds and release its lien. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac standard short sale guidelines allow a short sale even when the loan is current, as long as there is an eligible hardship, which makes it a genuine option for landlords who want to exit a property that no longer makes financial sense.

For a short sale to close, the lender must approve the reduced payoff amount in writing. You should also ask for a written release of any remaining balance. Under Florida Statute 702.036, a lender's ability to pursue the forgiven balance after a short sale is limited for purchase-money mortgages, but for other loans you need the release in writing to protect yourself.

A short sale on a rental with tenants requires planning around the lease. The buyer takes title subject to the tenants' rights under the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act, which can affect the sale price and the buyer pool. Investors who buy rental properties often prefer tenants in place, so this is not necessarily a problem, but it must be handled correctly.

Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure

A deed in lieu transfers the property directly to the lender in exchange for the lender releasing the mortgage obligation. It avoids the time and cost of a judicial foreclosure, and it is usually faster and less damaging to your credit than a completed foreclosure.

Lenders generally require the property to be vacant or the tenants to be handled properly before they accept a deed in lieu. Because the lender becomes the owner, it inherits the tenant situation, so most lenders want the property delivered vacant. That can mean waiting for leases to expire, negotiating with tenants, or completing an eviction first.

As with a short sale, the anti-deficiency protection in Florida Statute 702.036 applies to purchase-money mortgages. For other loans, negotiate a written release of the unpaid balance before you sign the deed, and have a Florida real estate attorney review the agreement.

Foreclosure and Your Tenants

Florida foreclosures are judicial, meaning they go through the circuit court. The process takes months, and during that time your tenants generally keep paying rent and keep their rights under the lease.

The federal Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act protects bona fide tenants when a residential property is sold at foreclosure. The new owner must either honor the existing lease or give at least 90 days written notice before eviction, whichever is greater. Tenants on a month-to-month lease also get at least 90 days notice. A purchaser who will occupy the home as a primary residence can end the tenancy with 90 days notice.

To be protected, the tenant must be bona fide: the lease must be at market rent or subsidized rent, and it must not have been created to evade foreclosure. Tenants who are not bona fide, for example a family member living there rent-free under a lease created after the foreclosure started, have fewer protections.

For you as the landlord, the practical point is that a foreclosure does not instantly empty the property. Plan for the tenant timeline, communicate honestly with your tenants, and consider whether a negotiated exit such as a cash-for-keys agreement serves everyone better than a long foreclosure process.

Your Main Options

There is no single right answer for every landlord. Here are the main paths, who each one may fit, and the tradeoffs to weigh.

Work With Your Servicer to Catch Up

What it is: Request forbearance, a repayment plan, or a Flex Modification so you can keep the property and get current.

Who it may fit: Landlords with a short-term hardship, positive or fixable cash flow, and a desire to keep the investment.

Potential advantages: You keep the asset, avoid a sale, and protect your tenants from disruption.

Potential drawbacks and risks: Options for investment properties are often less generous than for primary homes, the modification may extend your loan term, and you must be able to sustain the new payment.

Short Sale

What it is: Sell the rental for less than the mortgage balance with lender approval, including while the loan is current if you have an eligible hardship.

Who it may fit: Landlords who owe more than the property is worth, or who cannot sustain the payments and want to exit in an orderly way.

Potential advantages: Avoids foreclosure, and Florida Statute 702.036 limits deficiency pursuit on purchase-money mortgages.

Potential drawbacks and risks: The lender must approve the price and release the lien, the process takes time, and a non-purchase-money loan may still expose you to the unpaid balance unless you get a written release.

Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure

What it is: Transfer the property to the lender in exchange for release of the mortgage obligation.

Who it may fit: Landlords who cannot sell, cannot keep the property, and want to avoid a full foreclosure.

Potential advantages: Faster and often less damaging to credit than foreclosure, with the same 702.036 purchase-money protection.

Potential drawbacks and risks: Lenders usually want the property vacant, so you may need to resolve tenant leases first, and you still need a written release for any non-purchase-money balance.

Sell With Tenants in Place

What it is: List the rental on the open market with the lease intact, or sell directly to an investor who wants immediate rental income.

Who it may fit: Landlords with reliable tenants, a property that is worth more than the loan, and time to sell.

Potential advantages: The sale proceeds can pay off the loan without a short sale, and tenant-occupied properties appeal to investors.

Potential drawbacks and risks: The market may discount the price for the existing lease, the sale takes time, and you keep carrying taxes, insurance, and maintenance while it is listed.

Cash Sale to an Investor

What it is: Sell the property as-is, in its current condition, to a cash buyer or investor who closes quickly without lender financing.

Who it may fit: Landlords with deferred maintenance, problem tenants, or a need to close fast and move on.

Potential advantages: Speed, certainty, no repairs, and no financing contingencies. If the offer covers the loan, it avoids a short sale entirely.

Potential drawbacks and risks: Cash offers are typically below retail value, and you still must handle the tenant lease and any shortfall if the offer is below the loan balance.

Let Foreclosure Proceed

What it is: Stop making payments and allow the lender to complete a judicial foreclosure in Florida circuit court.

Who it may fit: Landlords with no equity, no way to sell, and no ability to negotiate, who understand the credit and deficiency consequences.

Potential advantages: No further effort or expense on your part, and the process is governed by strict court timelines.

Potential drawbacks and risks: A foreclosure stays on your credit for years, a deficiency judgment may follow for non-purchase-money loans, and your tenants face an uncertain timeline under the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act.

Questions to Ask Before You Decide

  • What loss mitigation options does my servicer offer for an investment property, and what documentation do I need to provide?
  • Is my loan a purchase-money mortgage, and does Florida Statute 702.036 protect me, or do I need a written release of the unpaid balance?
  • What is the property worth, what do I owe, and would a sale actually cover the payoff?
  • What do my tenants' leases say, and how do the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act protections affect a sale or foreclosure timeline?
  • If I sell at a gain, would a 1031 exchange make sense, and what are the 45-day and 180-day deadlines?
  • Have I asked a Florida real estate attorney to review my loan documents and any short sale or deed in lieu agreement before I sign?

How to Decide

Start with three numbers: what you owe, what the property is worth, and what the monthly shortfall is between your rent and your costs. Then add your tenant situation and your timeline.

If the shortfall is temporary and you can sustain the property after a modification, working with your servicer is usually the first conversation to have. If you owe less than the property is worth and want out, a sale with tenants in place or a cash sale can pay off the loan cleanly. If you owe more than it is worth, a short sale may be the orderly exit, and a deed in lieu is the backup when a sale is not possible. If none of those work, foreclosure is the last resort, and you should understand the credit and deficiency consequences before you stop paying.

No outcome is guaranteed, and no one option is right for everyone. The goal is to compare the paths with accurate numbers and honest tenant planning, then choose the one that fits your finances and your goals.

Florida Considerations

Recourse state. Florida lenders can generally pursue the unpaid balance after foreclosure, short sale, or deed in lieu. Florida Statute 702.036 limits that pursuit for purchase-money mortgages on short sales and deeds in lieu, but owner-occupied anti-deficiency protections do not extend to investment properties.

Judicial foreclosure. Florida foreclosures go through circuit court, which takes months and gives you time to negotiate, sell, or arrange an exit, but also means the process is public.

Tenant protections. The Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act requires the new owner to honor a bona fide lease or give at least 90 days notice, and month-to-month tenants get at least 90 days. Plan every sale and foreclosure around this timeline.

Rising costs. Florida property insurance, taxes, and HOA fees have risen sharply, squeezing landlord margins. If the numbers no longer work even after a modification, an exit may be the financially sound choice.

A Hypothetical Example

David owns a three-bedroom rental in Orange County. He refinanced the property two years ago to pull out cash, so his loan is not a purchase-money mortgage. After his insurance premium doubled and a tenant lost his job and stopped paying, David falls 90 days behind. The property is worth about $290,000 and he owes $310,000.

David calls his servicer and learns the Flex Modification is evaluated for his 90-plus-day delinquency. The servicer offers terms that reduce his payment by about 20 percent, but David realizes the rent still will not cover the full cost, and he does not want to keep subsidizing the property. He asks about a short sale. The servicer approves a sale at $285,000 with a written release of the remaining $25,000, because he negotiates it as part of the approval. His tenant has a month-to-month lease, so the buyer gives the tenant 90 days notice under the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act, and David helps the tenant find a new place with a cash-for-keys agreement.

The point is not that David's path is right for everyone. It is that he acted early, asked about every option, negotiated the deficiency release in writing, and planned for his tenant. That is the same process any Florida landlord can follow.

Your Next Steps

1

Call Your Servicer Early

Ask which loss mitigation options are available for an investment property and what documents you need to provide. Early contact keeps more options open.

2

Review Your Loan Documents

Determine whether the loan is a purchase-money mortgage and whether you personally guaranteed it. This tells you your deficiency exposure.

3

Get Real Numbers

Ask a licensed Florida real estate professional for a market value estimate, an as-is cash offer, and a comparison of what each path leaves you with after costs.

4

Plan for Your Tenants

Review your leases, understand the Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act protections, and decide whether tenants stay, receive notice, or negotiate a cash-for-keys exit.

5

Get the Release in Writing

If you do a short sale or deed in lieu on a non-purchase-money loan, negotiate a written release of the unpaid balance and have a Florida real estate attorney review it.

6

Compare Your Options

Talk through the full set of options with a licensed Florida real estate professional who handles both traditional and distressed sales. Tyler Gibson speaks Spanish and can help you compare your choices.

Not Sure What to Do With Your Rental Property?

Tyler Gibson is a Florida real estate professional and investor who helps landlords understand their options when a rental property becomes a burden. He speaks Spanish. There is no cost to talk through your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I get a loan modification or forbearance on a rental property?
Yes, servicers of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans must follow a loss mitigation workout hierarchy that applies to investment properties, starting with retention options such as forbearance, repayment plans, and the Flex Modification. For a conventional loan on a rental, the Flex Modification is typically evaluated once the loan is 90 or more days delinquent, and it targets about a 20 percent payment reduction. Borrowers who are less than 60 days delinquent usually face stricter conditions, including that the property is their primary residence, which a rental is not. Terms for investment properties are often less generous than for a primary home, so ask your servicer for the specific options available on your loan.
Can I do a short sale on a rental property in Florida?
Yes. A short sale on a rental property requires your lender's approval of a sale price below the mortgage balance and its agreement to release the lien. Florida Statute 702.036 limits a lender's ability to pursue the forgiven balance after a short sale or deed in lieu on a purchase-money mortgage. If your loan is not a purchase-money mortgage, you may still face deficiency exposure, so negotiate a written release of the unpaid balance before closing and have a Florida real estate attorney review the agreement.
What happens to my tenants if my rental property is foreclosed?
The federal Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act protects bona fide tenants in foreclosed residential properties. The new owner must either honor the existing lease or give at least 90 days written notice before eviction, whichever is greater. Month-to-month tenants also get at least 90 days notice. A purchaser who will occupy the home as a primary residence may be able to end the tenancy with 90 days notice. The lease must be at market or subsidized rent and must not have been created to evade foreclosure.
Can I sell a rental property with tenants in place?
Yes. In Florida the sale transfers the property subject to the existing lease, and the new owner becomes the landlord under the same lease terms. Many investors prefer to buy with tenants in place because the property produces immediate rental income. If you need to deliver the property vacant, you may wait for the lease to expire, negotiate a cash-for-keys agreement, or pursue eviction only if the tenant violates the lease or fails to pay rent.
Am I personally liable if my rental property goes to foreclosure?
It depends on the loan. Florida is a recourse state, and after a foreclosure the lender may pursue a deficiency judgment for the difference between the debt and the sale price. Florida Statute 702.036 provides anti-deficiency protections for short sales and deeds in lieu on purchase-money mortgages, and Florida law protects owner-occupied homes of four units or fewer from deficiency judgments in some foreclosure situations, but investment properties generally do not receive that protection. A Florida attorney can review your loan documents and tell you what exposure you face.
Can I evict a tenant just to sell the property?
No. You cannot evict a tenant solely because you want to sell, unless the lease allows termination upon sale or the tenant is violating the lease. Florida eviction requires proper written notice (3-day notice for nonpayment, 7-day notice for lease violations, 15-day notice for month-to-month tenancies), a court filing, and a hearing. Many landlords instead negotiate a cash-for-keys agreement, where the tenant agrees to move out in exchange for payment, which is usually faster and less expensive than an eviction.

Sources and Further Reading

  • Fannie Mae, Loss Mitigation and Non-Retention Options (short sale, deed in lieu) - singlefamily.fanniemae.com
  • Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, Flex Modification eligibility - servicing-guide.fanniemae.com
  • FHFA, Standard Short Sale Guidelines for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac - fhfa.gov
  • Florida Statute 702.036 (Limitations on deficiency judgments after short sale or deed in lieu) - flsenate.gov
  • Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act (permanently authorized 2018) - nlihc.org
  • National Housing Law Project, Tenants and Foreclosure - nhlp.org
  • Florida Statutes Chapter 83 (Landlord and Tenant) - flsenate.gov
  • IRS, Like-Kind Exchanges under Section 1031 - irs.gov
Call Now